Frankly, my first reaction to this article about how various scientific groups are asking people to donate increasingly drastic amounts of personal data for research benefits was fairly simple:
I'm pretty sure I've seen this plot line before... and it didn't exactly end well for the protagonists. In fact, the misuse of the data the protagonist provided set up the villains' entire plan. (A Certain Scientific Railgun S, in case anyone is wondering exactly what anime I was thinking of.)
However, for all my random anime references, I am capable of recognizing the good that can come out of this sort of thing as well. I think we need to be careful about churning through massive amounts of data hunting for any useful pattern, because when one does that sort of thing, patterns tend to show up whether they are significant and useful or not. But some of the things we find by taking advantage of our ability to analyze all of this data and recheck other conclusions against it will certainly be useful.
As the article notes, I think the key is going to be in robust notification about how and why that data is being used. Part of the utility of such giant data requests is going to be in using them for whatever comes up, but doing so without ensuring that the donors know where their information is going could all too easily lead to serious problems. The only way to safeguard against it is to make sure that donors are notified when a new project that would use their data is proposed.
Disclaimer
The content on this blog is my personal opinion and does not reflect the views of the Department of Defense or the US Navy in any way.
Tuesday, June 26, 2018
Monday, June 25, 2018
The Importance of Turnout
I like reading articles about how we study voting patterns and how we determine what does and doesn't improve turnout. To be blunt, that's mostly because I think the generally poor turnout in the US is an urgent problem facing our democracy, and because I like having new ways to talk about it and new evidence to point to.
I've never been that happy with the simplest expedient of urging people to vote and shaming them when they don't. It certainly can have an effect, but I think we do better by ourselves and our friends when we look at ways to play up the impact voting has or how to make it easier to do without compromising the accuracy of our vote.
This article is a case in point. It shows how a simple comparison between areas in the US can tell us a lot about this problem, it gives us more information about what sort of benefits are good and which aren't worth the trouble, and it offers a simple solution. That does also suggest that we should be willing to make seemingly large changes in our system; I'm sure some people wouldn't consider changing how and when we submit our votes simple or minor.
That article also does call out one point I think is important: I don't actually believe that fraud is currently enough of a problem to justify measures that will severely depress turnout. Our system can more easily survive fraud at current levels than it can survive even more people not voting because they don't feel they have the time or money to secure everything they need.
I've never been that happy with the simplest expedient of urging people to vote and shaming them when they don't. It certainly can have an effect, but I think we do better by ourselves and our friends when we look at ways to play up the impact voting has or how to make it easier to do without compromising the accuracy of our vote.
This article is a case in point. It shows how a simple comparison between areas in the US can tell us a lot about this problem, it gives us more information about what sort of benefits are good and which aren't worth the trouble, and it offers a simple solution. That does also suggest that we should be willing to make seemingly large changes in our system; I'm sure some people wouldn't consider changing how and when we submit our votes simple or minor.
That article also does call out one point I think is important: I don't actually believe that fraud is currently enough of a problem to justify measures that will severely depress turnout. Our system can more easily survive fraud at current levels than it can survive even more people not voting because they don't feel they have the time or money to secure everything they need.
Saturday, June 23, 2018
Anime review: Sword Art Online: Ordinal Scale
So apparently including a mysterious diva in a anime movie is a great way to get me to like it - it worked with the Index/Railgun movie, and now it's working again with SAO.
... Okay, that's not the only reason.
For anyone not familiar with it, Sword Art Online is a book series, which got made into a TV anime series, which has spawned a truly ridiculous number of spin-off manga, anime, and games. It focuses on two gamers, Kirito and Asuna, who are some of the first players to join a virtual reality online game using a system that allows them to completely dive into the game's world... only to discover that they can't log out or shut down the system in order to return to the real world, and that dying in the game will cause the system to kill them in real life as well.
It has its problems; Kirito in particular often reaches Boring Invincible Hero levels of power for no apparent reason. But it's still one of my favorite series of all time, because I greatly enjoy the way it brings up issues and philosophical questions that are quite relevant to the world we live in.
The SAO movie - which is set after all of the currently released seasons of the anime, so spoilers not just for the movie but for the entire anime run may follow - certainly follows in the TV anime's footsteps in that regard. And that's not even the only reason to like it!
In its case, one of the major details driving the plot is the memories many of the characters have of the time they spent forced to remain in the original game world - and one of the justifications the villains use is that they dismiss the value of those memories and assume that everyone who was forced to risk their lives to try and clear the game would rather forget all of it because of the stress and fear involved. It builds nicely on one of the messages from the original anime; namely, that what we do in a virtual world - whether that's an actual game or anything else online - can still be a very real, significant part of who we are.
The movie also avoided a lot of the traps that the original anime fell into. The villains' plot was easily understandable; it made sense that they would want to do the things they did, even if they were evil. The advantages they had were telegraphed, but not so clearly as to ruin everything before the dramatic moment in which Kirito figures the problem out. And while it took a minute for me to understand why one of the final sequences was necessary for the main characters to win, it did become clear in the end why that needed to be a part of the plot.
Overall, I'm quite glad with the movie... now they just need to hurry up and get to the next seasons of the anime that they're planning to release.
Friday, June 22, 2018
Global Warming Predictions
Thirty years ago, a scientist named James Hansen testified before Congress about the dangers of global warming and his predictions for what global warming would look like.
Amusingly, both supporters and skeptics of global warming are claiming that the actual warming over the last thirty years supports their point of view. Or perhaps the word I'm looking for is "irritatingly". It's a little bit of both.
The skeptical article from the Wall Street Journal claims that what we've actually observed matches Hansen's third scenario the most closely - that was the scenario in which emissions stopped increasing in 2000. Of course, right after the note that "Global surface temperature has not increased significantly since 2000," comes the caveat: "...discounting the larger-than-usual El Niño of 2015-16."
I'll grant that whether the first half of that comment is true or not (I don't think it is, to be clear) does depend a bit on how one defines "significant" warming. Even without debating that point, though, discounting El Niño years doesn't seem like a great idea to me - or, at least, if you're going to do it, you should also take into account the effects like La Niña that might result in cooler temperatures. For example, you could compare trend lines for just the El Niño years, or just the La Niña years, or just the neutral years. If you do something like that - as seen in this article - you get a fairly clear picture of how temperatures are still getting warmer.
Thursday, June 21, 2018
Facts and Opinions
This Pew study on how good Americans are at distinguishing between factual and opinion statements in the news is simultaneously awesome, depressing, and a bit encouraging. I like it a lot, because I think trying to measure this sort of thing is extremely interesting, but the results they came up with are mixed at best.
Of course, if you want to try your hand at telling the difference, you can do that here.
The study does offer some reason for optimism - over half of the people in the survey group were able to get a majority of the questions correct. Each question was also answered correctly by a majority of the people who responded, although in one or two cases it was a very small majority. And I liked noting that people who are very politically aware and who trust the news media tended to do better than those that didn't, because it shows there actually might be some benefit in trying to keep people informed.
On the other hand, there weren't very many people that actually managed to get all of the statements right, and the way in which errors showed up pretty clearly shows that a lot of the public is quite willing to engage in motivated reasoning, whether or not they realize that's what they're doing.
Of course, if you want to try your hand at telling the difference, you can do that here.
The study does offer some reason for optimism - over half of the people in the survey group were able to get a majority of the questions correct. Each question was also answered correctly by a majority of the people who responded, although in one or two cases it was a very small majority. And I liked noting that people who are very politically aware and who trust the news media tended to do better than those that didn't, because it shows there actually might be some benefit in trying to keep people informed.
On the other hand, there weren't very many people that actually managed to get all of the statements right, and the way in which errors showed up pretty clearly shows that a lot of the public is quite willing to engage in motivated reasoning, whether or not they realize that's what they're doing.
Wednesday, June 20, 2018
Judicial Discretion and Bail
Add this to the myriad list of ways in which our justice system is not as scrupulously fair as it really needs to be: the way in which it determines who gets bail and who doesn't can vary quite a bit depending on exactly what judge is in charge.
... Well, okay, I'll qualify that a little bit. I'd really like more data, because it's difficult to tell what the proper exercise of the average judge's discretion is supposed to look like.
Certainly, the numbers in this article seem to argue that the difference is too wide to be explained by anything other than differences in the criteria used by various judges. In particular, the fact that there are differences between judges working in the same area needs a convincing explanation, because I expect their case loads would feature similar types of people. It's hard to believe that one judge just happens to get a majority of people who cannot be trusted to return without bail and another judge gets a majority of people who can be released on their own recognizance. And the anecdotes featured later in the article support the idea that there's quite a bit of subjectivity in this process.
That said, I think a proper measure of success in this matter is less about how similar all the judges' numbers are and more about how many decisions they make correctly. If all the judges were closer to the median, it would still be possible that all of them were being too lenient or too harsh. Which is why I say I want more data; ensuring we are applying bail equally would certainly be better than the current state, but I see no reason not to aim for the right balance between ensuring our justice system can still function and avoiding as much damage as possible to defendants' lives.
Unfortunately, figuring out where we were overly harsh would be extremely difficult, since I don't know of any good way to figure out who out of the people held on bail would have returned even without that incentive. Figuring out where we were too lenient, on the other hand, seems like it would be quite easy - those are the people who were released on their own recognizance (or with a very small bail) and don't return for their trials. That suggests to me that a good judge should err on the side of leniency but keep track of how many people aren't coming back in order to ensure that they aren't going too far.
Tuesday, June 19, 2018
Mistaken Arguments
Here's a fun question to ponder: Does making a mistake as you debate an issue automatically mean you're wrong?
The short answer is no - this is formally called the argument from fallacy (although I prefer fallacy fallacy myself).
It's come up as I see liberals being criticized on social media and in other areas for a few of the pictures featuring detained children. Some of them were actually from President Obama's term. Others were from protests or otherwise aren't actually detained immigrants. All of them leave the left looking more than a bit foolish.
... and it still doesn't change the simple fact that immigrant parents are being separated from their children.
Nor does it change the fact that it is within President Trump's power to unilaterally resolve the issue. He doesn't even have to refuse to prosecute some immigrants; all he has to do is instruct the authorities to set a date for them to come back for hearings/trials and then let them go. Some of them won't come back, sure, but I'd rather be dealing with that problem than the one we have right now.
So if you want to make some liberals look like fools, sure, you can keep bringing up points like this. In the end, though, it's not going to bring us any closer to a resolution on this issue, because doing so doesn't actually make those liberals wrong.
The short answer is no - this is formally called the argument from fallacy (although I prefer fallacy fallacy myself).
It's come up as I see liberals being criticized on social media and in other areas for a few of the pictures featuring detained children. Some of them were actually from President Obama's term. Others were from protests or otherwise aren't actually detained immigrants. All of them leave the left looking more than a bit foolish.
... and it still doesn't change the simple fact that immigrant parents are being separated from their children.
Nor does it change the fact that it is within President Trump's power to unilaterally resolve the issue. He doesn't even have to refuse to prosecute some immigrants; all he has to do is instruct the authorities to set a date for them to come back for hearings/trials and then let them go. Some of them won't come back, sure, but I'd rather be dealing with that problem than the one we have right now.
So if you want to make some liberals look like fools, sure, you can keep bringing up points like this. In the end, though, it's not going to bring us any closer to a resolution on this issue, because doing so doesn't actually make those liberals wrong.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)