The number of Republican leaders that have made statements against our current policy to separate adults and children detained for illegal immigration is certainly a rather nice thing to see. It would be nicer, though, if it actually looked like it was going to result in a change to that policy. Right now it seems like the administration is still insisting on a compromise that changes the policy in exchange for the usual Republican wish list: tougher enforcement, money for the wall, etc.
Which does kind of beg the question: why is a compromise even necessary? Both sides seem to want family separation to end, so why do we need to worry about who wants other things and what we're willing to trade for them?
I think it helps throw some light on things if we look at how we got here. Well, that and I want to spell out exactly how what President Trump is doing is different from what was done under previous administrations.
President Obama did face similar problems when he was trying to figure out what to do with families of illegal immigrants, and he took quite a bit of criticism for his detention centers. The critical difference, though, is that President Obama's solution was to put the whole family in a detention center together. The major problem that came up was that it's not actually legal to keep minors in detention for that long (this is because of the Flores lawsuit that frequently gets mentioned), whether or not their parents are with them. As far as I know, there was never actually a solution to this; President Obama left office with the question unresolved. Some families were just let go, some were allowed out of detention pending trial, and some remained in detention contrary to the federal courts' orders.
Then President Trump entered office. As far as I can tell, he has absolutely zero interest in making immigration enforcement any harder than it has to be, so the first two options that involve letting people out of jail are out. And he also doesn't want to detain the kids longer than he is legally allowed to. Which means the kids are removed from detention, and the parents stay. I suppose he probably doesn't want to separate families, but he also doesn't want to let people out of detention pending trial, and he certainly doesn't want to not charge them at all.
Which sets up the compromise, as the Republicans see it: First, they give up on demanding pre-trial detention, both making it harder to enforce immigration law, which they don't want, and avoiding separating families, which they do want. But, since that's neutral overall for them, they're also going to demand something they actually want out of the whole situation.
It also, however, sets up my response for my Republican friends: If you're only willing to avoid separating families because you get something else you want out of it, then it's going to look like you don't care about the problem all that much, and you will take some criticism for it. If you want to avoid that outcome, you may have to give up on getting as much as you originally wanted out of this situation.
Disclaimer
The content on this blog is my personal opinion and does not reflect the views of the Department of Defense or the US Navy in any way.
Monday, June 18, 2018
Saturday, June 16, 2018
Game review: Budget Cuts
Because of course the right response to automation taking your coworkers' jobs is to sneak through your office and assassinate all the robots that have been taking their jobs with office supplies (e.g. scissors, letter openers) on your way to discuss the matter with the CEO.
... Wait, that's not the right answer? Well, that's what the main character has to do in Budget Cuts. All of your human coworkers keep getting summoned to meetings with HR, and they're not being seen again (at all, I mean, not just in the "they're fired and leave immediately" sense). Luckily, a mysterious friend has sent you a pager and uses it to send you codes you can use to receive messages and advice from her - between that and your prototype teleporter, it's time to see if you can escape whatever fate has befallen your coworkers.
It really is worth it. The enemy units in the game can only see your head, so there's real benefit to crawling around on the floor in order to hide behind cubicle walls or climb through narrow ducts. Even though the primary movement is teleporting, there's also benefits to walking around in your play area to peer around corners or get exactly the right angle on a teleport. These feel like exactly the sort of mechanics that a VR game should be taking advantage of, even if they can be a bit hard on my knees. The throwing mechanics (the only way to kill enemies) feel a bit frustrating to me - it's really hard to actually hit anything more than a few feet away, and quickly upgrades to impossible if the anything in question is actually moving - but it's also possible that I just suck at throwing things.
The story is certainly a bit silly, but still offers enough weird questions about the exact nature of what's going on to keep you engaged the whole way through. About my only concern there is that the game (like many other current VR offerings) is a bit short, and it ends with the dreaded "to be continued" - which was an irritatingly unexpected lack of a concrete end to the story.
... of course, it's not going to stop me from buying the continuation, when or if it comes out. Indeed, I look forward to seeing what else these people come up with.
... Wait, that's not the right answer? Well, that's what the main character has to do in Budget Cuts. All of your human coworkers keep getting summoned to meetings with HR, and they're not being seen again (at all, I mean, not just in the "they're fired and leave immediately" sense). Luckily, a mysterious friend has sent you a pager and uses it to send you codes you can use to receive messages and advice from her - between that and your prototype teleporter, it's time to see if you can escape whatever fate has befallen your coworkers.
It really is worth it. The enemy units in the game can only see your head, so there's real benefit to crawling around on the floor in order to hide behind cubicle walls or climb through narrow ducts. Even though the primary movement is teleporting, there's also benefits to walking around in your play area to peer around corners or get exactly the right angle on a teleport. These feel like exactly the sort of mechanics that a VR game should be taking advantage of, even if they can be a bit hard on my knees. The throwing mechanics (the only way to kill enemies) feel a bit frustrating to me - it's really hard to actually hit anything more than a few feet away, and quickly upgrades to impossible if the anything in question is actually moving - but it's also possible that I just suck at throwing things.
The story is certainly a bit silly, but still offers enough weird questions about the exact nature of what's going on to keep you engaged the whole way through. About my only concern there is that the game (like many other current VR offerings) is a bit short, and it ends with the dreaded "to be continued" - which was an irritatingly unexpected lack of a concrete end to the story.
... of course, it's not going to stop me from buying the continuation, when or if it comes out. Indeed, I look forward to seeing what else these people come up with.
Friday, June 15, 2018
Disruptive Innovation and Incremental Improvements
I'll go ahead and say it: I don't actually like Elon Musk very much.
Well, perhaps that's going a bit far. I give him a lot of credit for his willingness to move forward with bold projects and new ideas, even when it comes with a fair bit of personal expense or risk. I think some of his ideas are legitimately quite awesome and the sort of things we're going to need as we continue trying to make some of our science fiction into reality.
However, the confidence with which he tends to push everything he's involved in doesn't always mesh well with the reality that some experiments and innovation fail. That confidence becomes downright annoying when an would-be innovator tries to disrupt an existing field and force it to change for the sake of an idea that isn't going to work.
... And that brings me to Elon Musk and mass transit, whether it's his first Hyperloop concept or his most recent deal to build high-speed rail between Chicago O'Hare Airport and the city center.
Here's the problem: We know how to build a commercially viable train system. They're in operation in countless parts of the world. The fact that the US is not one of those places does theoretically argue that a more innovative idea would help... but before we try to totally reinvent mass transit, I'd argue that actually following some of the best practices the rest of the world uses might help. At least if we're going to propose more innovative ideas, we should probably try to avoid making them worse than what we already know how to do!
What really baffles me about the whole thing is that Elon Musk is clearly not stupid - otherwise he'd not have succeeded in so many different ways. And yet proposing something that has so much less carrying capacity than a typical subway and calling it "high capacity" seems like an obvious error, nor is it the only such problem with his mass transit ideas. That's probably the biggest reason why I have a more general dislike of Musk instead of stopping at just questioning how well things like this will work.
Well, perhaps that's going a bit far. I give him a lot of credit for his willingness to move forward with bold projects and new ideas, even when it comes with a fair bit of personal expense or risk. I think some of his ideas are legitimately quite awesome and the sort of things we're going to need as we continue trying to make some of our science fiction into reality.
However, the confidence with which he tends to push everything he's involved in doesn't always mesh well with the reality that some experiments and innovation fail. That confidence becomes downright annoying when an would-be innovator tries to disrupt an existing field and force it to change for the sake of an idea that isn't going to work.
... And that brings me to Elon Musk and mass transit, whether it's his first Hyperloop concept or his most recent deal to build high-speed rail between Chicago O'Hare Airport and the city center.
Here's the problem: We know how to build a commercially viable train system. They're in operation in countless parts of the world. The fact that the US is not one of those places does theoretically argue that a more innovative idea would help... but before we try to totally reinvent mass transit, I'd argue that actually following some of the best practices the rest of the world uses might help. At least if we're going to propose more innovative ideas, we should probably try to avoid making them worse than what we already know how to do!
What really baffles me about the whole thing is that Elon Musk is clearly not stupid - otherwise he'd not have succeeded in so many different ways. And yet proposing something that has so much less carrying capacity than a typical subway and calling it "high capacity" seems like an obvious error, nor is it the only such problem with his mass transit ideas. That's probably the biggest reason why I have a more general dislike of Musk instead of stopping at just questioning how well things like this will work.
Thursday, June 14, 2018
School Choice
The way both sides' battle lines are breaking down on a recent effort by NYC mayor Bill de Blasio to decrease the role that admissions exams play in gaining entrance to some of the best high schools in the city shouldn't surprise much of anyone. The Wall Street Journal's columnists call it "The Attack on Educational Excellence", whereas their counterparts from the New York Times are debating whether it's necessary to get rid of racism or not.
I actually don't quite like either side's position, although it shouldn't surprise much of anyone that I'm more sympathetic to the liberal argument than the conservative one.
So I'll start with my problem with my own side. Essentially, the notion that the admissions exam should play no role at all does seem a bit suspect to me. If nothing else, I don't think it does anyone much good to risk bringing in new students who are not prepared for the challenge facing them, nor do I think it does the school much good to give them a challenge their teachers may not be as ready to face as they think they are. Unfortunately, I don't think it's possible to keep the test as a means of ensuring that all of the prospective students are ready to succeed without it also being used to favor those prospective students that already have more resources and time to spend on preparing for it, but I also think that having something is necessary.
That said, the notions on the other side that teachers' unions are responsible for the inadequacy of our existing public schools - or that the solution is to abandon them entirely and rely on charter schools and the free market - is not even remotely true. Part of the reason I talked above about handing teachers a challenge they may not be ready for is that it turns out a lot of the really good schools that get cited by conservatives as examples of the free market's success got that way by not having to deal with students that might bring their numbers down. If the goal is to help everyone succeed, we don't have that option when dealing with the entire system.
In that sense, I think the point that the one NYT editorial makes is closest to the right answer - we need to be looking to make all of our schools into elite schools, and if that costs us a lot of money and effort, then so be it.
Wednesday, June 13, 2018
Detecting Evil
Today's inspiration is a nice piece from the Friendly Atheist about how abusers can manipulate church groups into taking their side and neglecting their victims.
Really, though, it's not just churches that have a problem with this. There are a lot of news stories of horrific crimes that feature friends and family of the culprit talking about how they were such a good person, and they can't believe that the culprit could possibly have done something like this. A lot of the rest feature people that were obviously kind of strange, but still not to the point that everyone around them took decisive action. (To be fair, the examples where something useful is done tend not to make the news as easily. It'd probably be interesting to try and analyze how often something slips past everyone versus how often things get caught, but I have no idea how one would even start to work on that.)
It seems that in real life it's a lot harder to detect evil than one might think. It's enough to make me decline to put that much stock in character references, particularly when they're used to question whether someone actually did hurt or insult someone else.
I think it's worth remembering for anyone that people can be more complicated than just how they act around you; just because you've never seen them act a different way isn't sufficient to prove that they never will or that they never have. That doesn't mean we have to automatically assume everyone around us is hiding some secret evil, and if someone has held to a given pattern of behavior around you, it's fair to trust that they will continue to do so. But if someone else says they act differently in other environments and around other people, your experience alone isn't sufficient to prove that accusation false.
Really, though, it's not just churches that have a problem with this. There are a lot of news stories of horrific crimes that feature friends and family of the culprit talking about how they were such a good person, and they can't believe that the culprit could possibly have done something like this. A lot of the rest feature people that were obviously kind of strange, but still not to the point that everyone around them took decisive action. (To be fair, the examples where something useful is done tend not to make the news as easily. It'd probably be interesting to try and analyze how often something slips past everyone versus how often things get caught, but I have no idea how one would even start to work on that.)
It seems that in real life it's a lot harder to detect evil than one might think. It's enough to make me decline to put that much stock in character references, particularly when they're used to question whether someone actually did hurt or insult someone else.
I think it's worth remembering for anyone that people can be more complicated than just how they act around you; just because you've never seen them act a different way isn't sufficient to prove that they never will or that they never have. That doesn't mean we have to automatically assume everyone around us is hiding some secret evil, and if someone has held to a given pattern of behavior around you, it's fair to trust that they will continue to do so. But if someone else says they act differently in other environments and around other people, your experience alone isn't sufficient to prove that accusation false.
Tuesday, June 12, 2018
Incremental Progress
So President Trump and Kim Jong Un signed an agreement at their summit today in Singapore. The text of it is available from pretty much any news site - I'll just post a link to this one because it's the one I had open while I was writing this.
I'm glad we did this. The agreement's not much; North Korea has broken deals with more weight behind them before. But if we want to lessen the risk of going to war with them, this is how we do it. Frankly, even if this doesn't ultimately lead to North Korea disarming and a more permanently peaceful relationship with them, I still think it's a good idea. It gives us more time at a lower risk of war, more time for the situation to change in other ways that might (or might not) take us closer to peace. It's not much of a chance, but it's still better than moving closer to war.
The one thing I'm not looking forward to is what I suspect we're all about to hear from President Trump's more ardent supporters. I strongly suspect they're going to cheer for the progress we're making... despite the fact that they've criticized other politicians in the past for even suggesting that we should take steps in this direction. That's probably uncharitable of me; I should just be happy that they're willing to support what I think is the right answer... but if these people are going to support this course of action now, is it too much to ask to hear them admit that means they were wrong before?
I'm glad we did this. The agreement's not much; North Korea has broken deals with more weight behind them before. But if we want to lessen the risk of going to war with them, this is how we do it. Frankly, even if this doesn't ultimately lead to North Korea disarming and a more permanently peaceful relationship with them, I still think it's a good idea. It gives us more time at a lower risk of war, more time for the situation to change in other ways that might (or might not) take us closer to peace. It's not much of a chance, but it's still better than moving closer to war.
The one thing I'm not looking forward to is what I suspect we're all about to hear from President Trump's more ardent supporters. I strongly suspect they're going to cheer for the progress we're making... despite the fact that they've criticized other politicians in the past for even suggesting that we should take steps in this direction. That's probably uncharitable of me; I should just be happy that they're willing to support what I think is the right answer... but if these people are going to support this course of action now, is it too much to ask to hear them admit that means they were wrong before?
Monday, June 11, 2018
The Value of a Discussion
File under the list of famous people believing stupid things: this interview of a basketball player in which he refuses to say that the earth is round, instead asking a bunch of questions about how we can prove it's round and talking about how irritated people get with him for questioning it.
So first, in the spirit of this XKCD comic: Yes, I can quite easily prove the earth is round. It's why objects traveling over the horizon disappear from the bottom up - something that anyone can go see for themselves by going down to a shoreline and watching ships sail away. The last thing you'll see is the ship's mast (although you'll probably need a decent pair of binoculars to get a good look). Even if you don't happen to live near a shoreline, you can run the same experiment yourself with any large flat area and a tall object - once you get far enough away from the tall object you've chosen, you'll only see the top of it. At that point all we need is a simple picture (not to scale, obviously) to show that this is what we'd expect to see if we live on a ball and there's our proof.
But there's a larger point to make about whether this sort of discussion is a good use of our time. I'll grant that it forces people to ask questions that help educate everyone around them, so there is some benefit to be found, but I'd still argue that it's not all that helpful. It doesn't help us discover anything new, it doesn't help illuminate what we do and don't value (or how we'd rank the things we value against each other)... it's just a simple "oh, you don't know this answer? Here it is".
Which is useful to some people, and we need to react to people in a way that allows them to ask the question in the first place. However, if that answer isn't acceptable, and the questioner wants to continue the discussion, at that point it is perfectly fair to ask them to produce reasons why the initial answer isn't sufficient - and to criticize them if they are unable or unwilling to provide good reasons. And the initial answer being a bit obscure or counter-intuitive at first glance is not generally a good reason.
One of the comments in that interview is "Does it really bother you that much that I think something different than you or that I actually want to have that conversation?" My answer is - if you don't have anything useful to say, then yes, it does bother me, because that's not a helpful discussion to have.
So first, in the spirit of this XKCD comic: Yes, I can quite easily prove the earth is round. It's why objects traveling over the horizon disappear from the bottom up - something that anyone can go see for themselves by going down to a shoreline and watching ships sail away. The last thing you'll see is the ship's mast (although you'll probably need a decent pair of binoculars to get a good look). Even if you don't happen to live near a shoreline, you can run the same experiment yourself with any large flat area and a tall object - once you get far enough away from the tall object you've chosen, you'll only see the top of it. At that point all we need is a simple picture (not to scale, obviously) to show that this is what we'd expect to see if we live on a ball and there's our proof.
But there's a larger point to make about whether this sort of discussion is a good use of our time. I'll grant that it forces people to ask questions that help educate everyone around them, so there is some benefit to be found, but I'd still argue that it's not all that helpful. It doesn't help us discover anything new, it doesn't help illuminate what we do and don't value (or how we'd rank the things we value against each other)... it's just a simple "oh, you don't know this answer? Here it is".
Which is useful to some people, and we need to react to people in a way that allows them to ask the question in the first place. However, if that answer isn't acceptable, and the questioner wants to continue the discussion, at that point it is perfectly fair to ask them to produce reasons why the initial answer isn't sufficient - and to criticize them if they are unable or unwilling to provide good reasons. And the initial answer being a bit obscure or counter-intuitive at first glance is not generally a good reason.
One of the comments in that interview is "Does it really bother you that much that I think something different than you or that I actually want to have that conversation?" My answer is - if you don't have anything useful to say, then yes, it does bother me, because that's not a helpful discussion to have.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)