Disclaimer


The content on this blog is my personal opinion and does not reflect the views of the Department of Defense or the US Navy in any way.


Wednesday, July 4, 2018

Patriotism's Meaning

I wonder how many people aren't really celebrating the 4th of July this year because they think their country no longer deserves the praise?

On one hand, I won't be doing the same; whatever else I may be, I'm still a patriot, I believe in the US, and I want us to keep doing well and growing stronger. On the other hand, that doesn't obligate me to agree with everything our country does or refrain from criticizing our decisions when I believe it's justified.

In fact, I think a true patriot has to avoid frantically trying to justify everything we do in order to avoid admitting error on our part. Wanting the best for our country and engaging in the sort of motivated reasoning necessary to avoid admitting error are contradictory, because the distorted view of reality the latter builds will interfere with any effort to actually improve the country and realize that dream of a just, virtuous, and powerful country. And that dream isn't something we can ever slap a "mission accomplished" label onto and then just rest on our laurels; it's something that will always be based on the effort we're currently putting into making our country great, how we're reacting to our errors, and how we're continuing to improve.

So I'll keep working to make sure we can do that, even as I recognize our country for the good we've done.

Happy 4th of July, everyone.

Tuesday, July 3, 2018

Philosophical Discussion

While I did study a bit of philosophy and ethics in college, I don't exactly follow the field that closely; I can't name any more interesting philosophers than the average person. So I don't really know the person that this piece from the New York Times is memorializing.

Then again, the article does highlight why I do pay quite a bit of attention when something about philosophy makes its way into my news feed - because simply reading it was surprisingly thought-provoking.

I'm not sure I even want to try summarizing it, or picking out just one point, because I don't think that would do it justice. However, I'm not confident it's something that most people will want to read all the way through (something that makes one think often takes more time and effort to comprehend, of course), so I'll go ahead and share the one point near the end which I found the most interesting. Specifically, it was this line: "This lesson is politically consequential, Cavell stresses, because it implies that thinking is an activity we can’t outsource to others."

My first reaction was actually not positive - mostly because I've always thought that expertise in finding, analyzing, and expressing information is something that can be outsourced in the same way we hire experts to do all number of tasks that we can't do ourselves. I can't fix a car, rewire a light fixture, or build anything besides a impossibly simple shelter, but I can ask someone else to do these things for me. And if I don't have time to analyze events around the world, determine their importance, and remember the most important ones all on my own, well, that was why I was reading the Times in the first place.

After some thought, though, I think I understand the point. What is true about it is that how I react to what I read, and how I choose to share that reaction, is still my own, unless I choose not to think about it. We're all better off if those reactions are based on thought, and not on unthinking copies of what others have said or want.

Monday, July 2, 2018

Purpose of the Justice System

Hardly the first time I've posted about the criminal justice system, but then, it's a topic that I think deserves a lot of attention. The ways in which it doesn't really produce fair or desirable results are myriad and fairly well documented, but discussions on the topic tend to founder on exactly who's responsible, why they're doing it, and whether doing something about it will make us less safe.

This post about what reasonable doubt means (the entire series is good, by the way) includes one particular point that I think is extremely relevant: "A justice system should want one thing and one thing only: the prevention of more people becoming victims of crime." This question of exactly what we want our justice system to do can have a significant impact on how we design it and where we spend our time and money.

There are a lot of people who argue that the proper purpose of the justice system is to ensure that criminals are captured and punished, but I think that's incomplete, at best. It's tempting to argue that some great ideal should drive us to ensure that those who do good in the world are rewarded and those who do evil should be punished, but if we really wanted to do that, there'd be a lot of other ways we'd be spending our time and money besides just designing a system to accomplish the latter. The other option is to justify the system's existence in utilitarian terms... which basically requires it to actually have a positive effect like reducing crime.


Saturday, June 30, 2018

Judicial Nominations

One of the reactions to Justice Kennedy's retirement that I saw pointed out that Republicans have nominated more justices to the Supreme Court in the last two or three decades despite the fact that the Democrats have won the popular vote (although not necessarily the presidency) more often in that time.

So I decided to go ahead and figure out how many nominations were made by each party, going back to the New Deal and FDR. It wasn't really that hard; Wikipedia's lists of Supreme Court justices and US presidents provided all the information I need.

It turns out the Democrats have it, albeit only barely; they nominated 21 justices since 1937, whereas the Republicans nominated 20. (Technically 19; I'm counting President Trump's impending nomination to replace Justice Kennedy.) Of course, just under half of the Democratic nominations came during FDR's very long time in office; remove his nine from the list, and the Republicans win easily.

In light of that, graphs like this one which show the median Supreme Court justice being on the conservative side more often than not over the time period in question aren't surprising. That's reassuring in some ways, since it implies that liberals can see results they like out of the Supreme Court even if things generally trend conservative... but that's still a very faint silver lining.

Friday, June 29, 2018

Reacting to the Truth

Here we go again.

This mass shooting is close enough to home that as it turns out, some people I've known for years have been deeply affected by it.

As it turns out, the gunman in this case had a personal grudge against the Capital Gazette; apparently he was a bit unhappy that they'd reported on a harassment case involving him, including the fact that he'd pled guilty. His efforts to sue the newspaper for their reporting were dismissed due to the simple fact that they had reported nothing but the truth. Unfortunately, it turns out some people would rather lash out in whatever way they can rather than accept that... and in a country with so many guns as ours, some of those people are going to lash out in that way.

Those people who lash out at the news media in other ways should take note: Your reaction being less extreme does not make it any more justified. If there's an actual error in reporting, it should be noted and corrected... but all too often, what we see instead is that people get unhappy because the truthful reports they see aren't telling them what they want to hear. That's not something our society can or should tolerate.

Thursday, June 28, 2018

Progress Report

With yesterday's post, I've now hit the second month in a row where I wrote more blog posts per month than in any of the years prior to this one. So I'm feeling pretty good about the level of effort I've managed to put into this project. I will note that much of the reason I started doing this was as a test for myself to see if I could maintain a useful level of effort, so I'm counting my primary goal met so far - and I'm not done yet, of course. (Next month, given the lack of expected distractions, should show me whether I can actually get up to posting 80% or 90% of the days of the month, for example.)

I would certainly be happier if more people were reading what I have to say, but there will be time to build up more of a following later if I decide it's worth the additional effort to do so. For now, for those of you that are reading, I'd like to take the chance to explicitly ask for feedback. What do you think of what you've read so far? Is there anything you'd like to see me do differently or any topics you specifically want to see me talk about?

Anything you have to say is welcome, whether it's something I can use to adjust, criticism of the way I think, or simply words of encouragement. Thanks for reading, and I hope you continue to do so!


Wednesday, June 27, 2018

Abortion and Free Speech

Believe it or not, I'm actually a bit conflicted over the result of the Supreme Court case regarding a crisis pregnancy center in California and the messages about abortion availability they were required to post.

I think the best way to put it is that I can easily understand how requiring someone to provide information about a service that wasn't even requested in the first place falls outside the scope of one's professional responsibility. If your entire practice is built around addressing a given problem in a specific way, and that's made clear to your customers at the outset, then requiring any more information about methods you don't provide may be a bit much.

... Of course, several caveats apply. Most CPCs, for example, would never dream of actually warning people that they will not provide any support or advice regarding abortion. Some of them will go so far as to actively lie about the risks of an abortion. If the people approaching you are looking to discuss all of their options when they're pregnant, either is almost certainly malpractice, and I have no problem with the state withholding licenses from organizations that operate that way.

So in the end, while I don't think I'd have gone as far as the California law that was struck down did, I'm irritated that the likely result is going to be these centers lying with more impunity, whether by omission or outright.

At least I can console myself with the fact that my side now gets to ask pointed questions about compelling speech designed to limit or discourage abortions. It's less useful for us; I do want to make sure that women are aware of all their options and wouldn't want to not give them a full picture of what carrying to term and either giving up the child for adoption or keeping them would entail. Still, I imagine it'd be a lot easier on some people if it could be omitted or reduced when it clearly made sense to do so.